I laugh in bewildered amusement whenever someone asks their social media friends: “Can you recommend a good dentist/orthodontist/pediatric dentist/etc?” You see, no matter how much you like your oral health care provider, you generally have no way of knowing how “good” they are.
Sure, you can attest to how clean and well decorated the office is, and how friendly the staff is and even as to whether they are gentle and kind when you’re being treated, but take it from someone who’s been in the field for almost a quarter of a century when I say that you simply can’t objectively evaluate your provider. You have no way of knowing if they are doing great work and I am sorry to report that when I was a general dentist, I often had the unenviable task of telling patients that the dental work their “friend” placed 3 years ago needed to be replaced because of decay or breakdown, even though it felt fine.
Aren’s the best dentists the busiest ones?
I’ve seen dentists whose patient absolutely loved them, with the most modern practices turn out work that was sub par, and I’ve seen some of the most gifted clinicians go bankrupt. So, how should patients go about finding a good provider? Well, there’s a difference in the process between general dentists and specialists because of how patients find them, and there’s a difference between different specialties because of how you can (or can’t) evaluate their results.
For instance, if you were looking for a cosmetic dentist to do veneers on your front teeth, you could get a pretty good idea by looking at the veneers he or she did on your best friend and determine whether or not they looked reasonable. Note: This can sometimes be tough because the best porcelain veneers are the ones you didn’t even know your friend had, right? But it’s a lot easier to judge a cosmetic dentist than, say, a periodontist who has helped your friend achieve a higher level of gum health.
Finding a good general dentist
Knowing what I know about general dentistry, if I were new to a town and looking for a great general practitioner (GP), I’d start by calling a few dental specialists. I’d take 15 minutes and call 10 offices of various dental specialists and tell them you were new to town and ask them “who is the best general dentist in town?” It’s an easy question, but the politics and friendships associated with business relationships will get a few offices referring you to someone with whom they are social but not necessarily the best. If a GP refers 20 patients a month to a specialist, the woman on the phone may be a little worried about referring you to someone else and undermining the relationship with their best referrer. That’s why I said to call 10 offices; you’ll see a few names emerge as a trend. Sounds like a lot of work? It’s only 15 minutes of your time!!! The people in dental offices have an opportunity (and knowledge) to objectively evaluate each other’s work in a far better way than the general public, who are untrained.
Finding a good dental specialist
If you need to see a specialist, you’re likely to have been given a few names from your general dentist (that’s if your GP refers, which is an altogether different blog post for the future). When I first started as a GP in 1992, I found out over time who were the best specialists in town and would exclusively refer just to them. If you needed braces, I would give you the name of my most trusted and best orthodontist. Those days are now gone. So as to not be liable for the referral given, many dentists now give several names and expect the patient to decide which one to go to. I don’t agree with that philosophy. Our patients count on us for advice and when my patients need an oral surgeon or pediatric dentist, I give them one name and only one name. If that’s the person I’d let treat me, why would I refer the patient to anyone else? Unfortunately, as I said, many dentists are going to give several names, so it’s going to be up to the patient to do their due diligence.
I would do the exact same thing as I just mentioned to find a GP, but in reverse. I would call 10 general dental offices and ask them: “Which endodontist/pediatric dentist/orthodontist/oral surgeon/periodontist/prosthodontist in the area would you go to for treatment?” The big difference is that general dentists don’t often rely on referrals from specialists so you’re likely to get a truly heartfelt answer from the person answering the phone. You’ll see a couple of names emerge and you can call them to figure out which one is right for you.
Figuring out which offices are truly the best
But your work isn’t done yet. Remember, nobody is more responsible for your dental and health choices than YOU!!! So, call the office(s) that emerged at the top of your list and tell them that you’re new to town and are looking to make an appointment. Observe the reception you get. The great offices will make you feel at home. They’ll ask you about YOU and who you are. They’ll give you details about what to expect and maybe even have welcome videos to send you. Warmth can’t be faked and it starts at the top of the practice. If you get put on hold for two minutes and they tell you what happens if you miss an appointment, it tells you a lot about the discussions this team has at their team meetings.
Ask them: “So tell me what makes Dr. X different than everyone else?” I guarantee you’ll catch them off guard and there won’t be a script. If they can only say “he’s a really nice guy and his patients love him” move on. I’d like to hear them say that the doctor spends a ton of free time attending continuing education classes, belongs to study clubs and perhaps even is a lecturer. You can’t fake those things.
Of course, when you go to the office it’s important that the dentist spend a fair amount of time with you. Whether you see the hygienist first and the dentist is an afterthought versus dedicated time first with the dentist is a very telling sign about the practice philosophy. Your heart will tell you whether the dentist cares about you or your child personally or if it’s all an act. Always listen to that little voice inside if it feels wrong.
Talk is cheap
Sure, it’s nice to hear that the doctor leads a “faith based life” or os “dedicated to his patients” but those are just words. You’re hopefully going to a dentist for the skill they display and kindness or gentleness is something you’ll be able to figure out on your own pretty quickly. But I have good news for you. There’s an objective way to differentiate offices.
Less than 1 in 15 general dentists ever achieve Fellowship in the Academy of General Dentistry. It’s a distinction which means that the GP took a certain amount of hours of continuing education in many areas, was a member of organized dentistry for a while and cared enough to take a written examination. It really isn’t difficult and is within the reach of any GP who really wants it. I got my certification when I was in practice for 7 years and it put me in an elite group of providers with the letters “FAGD” after their title. One can even go farther and become a “Master” within the Academy of General Dentistry (MAGD), an ever more rare distinction.
If you’re calling a specialist’s office, board certification is important. All specialists have to attend an accredited specialty program (though several recent court rulings have started muddying that definition) but board certification isn’t mandatory. To be a Diplomate in the American Board of Orthodontics, for instance, one must pass a written examination, travel to St. Louis with records of 6 treated patients and defend their clinical decisions and outcomes to a board of their peers. It can be a pretty stressful process.
With regard to Fellowship in the AGD or specialty board certification, you’l hear many clinicians say: “I could have done it but it wasn’t important to me” and it’s true that I know some great clinicians who haven’t achieved those distinctions. But the best clinicians I know in every specialty ARE board certified or and the best GPs I know ARE FAGDs. I wanted to stand out and PROVE to my patients that I was different and got my FAGD AND my board certification. As far as I know, I am the only clinician with those two distinctions and I’m proud of it. My patients can know that I have tangible proof of wanting to be the best I can be in my profession.
Find the one that’s right for you
Hopefully, you’ve gotten a better understanding of the complexities of finding an oral health provider who’s right for you. Asking a friend who they go to is a great first step, but I hope you can appreciate the laughable statement of patients who say “my dentist is the best” when what they really mean is “I really like my dentist”.
Good luck on your search and always feel free to contact me if you have any questions.
3 thoughts on “How Do I Find A Great Dentist?”
I like how you summarized your comments by talking about just finding the right dentist for you and your situation. It’s true that everyone looks for something different in who they select for their oral health, so no one answer is correct for everyone. Asking for referrals from friends really is a great idea, though, because it can get you started in the right direction. I also like taking a tour of the office before signing on as a patient — it really helps you know exactly what you’re paying for.
Great article. It’s funny how people gauge the quality of their dentist’s work by how they feel about it or just by the lack of any complications since they had the treatment. But you’re right that simply because it’s not painful does not mean the work is top notch. With that said, referrals can be helpful in terms of finding a dentist who makes you feel comfortable and more importantly, is good at communication. For general family dentists who treat children as well, communication and a friendly approach is super important.
I like your tip to call multiple general practitioners to see who they recommend. I also always like to find out what types of anesthesia a dentist uses as well. Sometimes they charge extra for some types, which is good to know as well.